The politics of water: Detroit, West Virginia, Gaza

My latest for Al Jazeera, on the water crisis in Detroit and beyond:

Detroit is one of the poorest cities in one of the wealthiest countries in the world. Detroit is also surrounded by the largest supply of fresh water in the world. The US does not lack for money, and Detroit does not lack for accessible water. What Detroit lacks are people viewed as worthy of the compassion and resources given to their richer, whiter peers. They lack the rights and respect most US citizens take for granted.

At a rally in June, life-long Detroiter Renla Session spoke out for her community: “These are my fellow human beings. If they threatened to cut off water to an animal shelter, you would see thousands of people out here. It’s senseless … They just treat people like their lives mean nothing here in Detroit, and I’m tired of it.”

When rights are considered privileges, only the privileged have rights.

“They treat people like animals in Detroit,” an auto worker complained in July, but the US treats its poorest citizens worse. When the government shut down in late 2013, the food programme for impoverished women and children was suspended – but the animals in the National Zoo stayed fed. More attention was paid to the shutdown of the PandaCam, a livestream of a bear cub, than to the suffering of the US’ poorest citizens.

Water is a human right, but who is a human being? Corporations, the US supreme court ruled in June, as the parched citizens of Detroit started filling up at water fountains.

“In its last day in session, the high court not only affirmed corporate personhood but expanded the human rights of corporations, who by some measures enjoy more protections than mortals – or ‘natural persons’,” wrote Dana Milbank at The Washington Post.

The mortals of Detroit enjoy no such protection. Perhaps that is why the city’s corporate venues – like its high-end golf club, hockey arena, football stadium, and over half of the city’s commercial and industrial users – still have their water running despite owing over $30m, while its most impoverished residents have their water, and their rights, taken away.

In Detroit, corporations are people. Their worth is unquestioned because it is measured in dollars. The worth of the residents of Detroit is measured in utility, and so their utilities are denied.

Read the full article, Water is a human right, but who is considered a human being? at Al Jazeera English.

This entry was posted in Uncategorized. Bookmark the permalink.

5 Responses to The politics of water: Detroit, West Virginia, Gaza

  1. zareenn3 says:

    It opens your eyes to all other countries and the crisis and makes you think all countries are more and less the same. Our government is more or less the same.
    Thank you so much for sharing and bringing light on this important subject.

  2. LeAnne says:

    Thank you for this story and your perspective on it. I have been taken aback by the way it’s been reported elsewhere; for example, on the radio show The Takeaway recently, access to water was framed as a question – right or privilege? – as if the matter should be up for debate:

  3. google says:

    We’re a bunch of volunteers and opening a new scheme in our community.
    Your web site offered us with useful info to work on. You have performed an impressive process
    and our entire community will be thankful to you.

  4. With this type of loan, the existing loan of
    the customer transfers to the new house that includes the extra amount that the
    customer requires. Though AMF, Alexander assisted
    borrowers to qualify for loans from Mesa Bank (now known as Sunrise Bank
    of Arizona). If you are reading this and no one has passed on, the best way to prepare for a funeral for a loved one is
    to either take out a guaranteed life insurance policy, enough to cover funeral expenses, or start
    a savings plan to cover funeral expenses.

  5. On the flipside, it is very important to realize that most loan products typically go hand in hand with banking guidelines.
    Another question they are going to require is if you have property and
    also the valuation on that land. The down payment
    required is somewhere between $1000-5000 down.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s